Avera St Lukes vs Methodist Healthcare - Olive Branch Hospital
Side-by-side hospital cost and quality comparison from CMS Medicare data
This comparison crosses state lines: Avera St Lukes (South Dakota) versus Methodist Healthcare - Olive Branch Hospital (Mississippi). Cost differences are influenced by the federal wage-index adjustment in addition to hospital-specific cost structure. The cost gap is moderate: $10,445 vs $11,543, about 10% apart. Enough to matter for high-volume procedures but not so wide that it dominates the choice. Avera St Lukes edges ahead on the value rubric.
The cost difference is enough to factor into elective scheduling for any procedure that both hospitals offer. For emergency or specialized care, the choice is often dictated by other factors.
Verdict
Avera St Lukes earns a higher Value Score of 86/100 (A) compared to Methodist Healthcare - Olive Branch Hospital at 86/100 (A). Average Medicare payment differs by $1,098 ($10,445 vs $11,543). Avera St Lukes holds a 5-star CMS rating.
| Metric | Avera St Lukes | Methodist Healthcare - Olive Branch Hospital |
|---|---|---|
| Value Score Composite of price, quality, and outcomes | 86/100 (A) | 86/100 (A) |
| CMS Quality Rating | ★★★★★ (5/5) | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Avg Payment Average Medicare payment across all procedures | $10,445* | $11,543 |
| Outcome Score | 50/100 | 58/100* |
| Emergency Services | Yes | Yes |
| Hospital Type | Acute Care Hospitals | Acute Care Hospitals |
| Ownership | Voluntary non-profit - Church | Voluntary non-profit - Private |
| Location | Aberdeen, SD | Olive Branch, MS |
| Procedures Tracked | 9 | 14 |
Avera St Lukes earns a higher Value Score of 86/100 (A) compared to Methodist Healthcare - Olive Branch Hospital at 86/100 (A). Average Medicare payment differs by $1,098 ($10,445 vs $11,543). Avera St Lukes holds a 5-star CMS rating.
Explore More
Source: CMS Hospital Price Transparency, 2026.